Rédaction Africa Links 24 with Susan Goldstein, Mark Tomlinson, Rachel Wynberg and Tanya Doherty
Published on 2024-03-12 16:10:26
In the year 2021, the director of the African Research Universities Alliance Centre of Excellence in Food Security at the University of Pretoria was appointed to the board of the transnational food corporation Nestlé. This appointment sparked concerns among over 200 senior academics who penned an open letter highlighting potential conflicts of interest. Nestlé’s food portfolio, as acknowledged by the company itself, consists of over 60% of products that do not meet the criteria of healthy goods.
Later in December 2023, the same research center entered into a memorandum of understanding with Nestlé, signaling a partnership aimed at influencing the future of food and nutrition research and education in Africa. This move raised questions about the ethical implications of collaborating with companies whose products may not contribute to health and well-being.
This practice of companies funding research and education in areas that may contradict public health goals is not limited to Nestlé alone. Other universities across Africa have also engaged in similar partnerships with corporations producing potentially harmful products. These collaborations often include activities such as internships, seminars, training programs, and sponsorships for graduate research students.
In South Africa, Nestlé has funded initiatives such as a prize in pediatrics for final-year medical students at the University of Witwatersrand and a two-year pediatric gastroenterology fellowship at Stellenbosch University. These sponsorships raise concerns about the influence of corporate funding on the direction and outcomes of research in the academic and health sectors.
The link between corporate funding and academic institutions has been widely recognized to lead to conflicts of interest. Research has shown that industry sponsorship can bias research outcomes consciously or unconsciously, affecting the integrity and reliability of scientific studies. Furthermore, the disclosure of financial or personal associations with interested parties may not always eliminate bias, whether intentional or subconscious.
The rise of noncommunicable diseases globally, linked to poor nutrition and unhealthy lifestyles, underscores the importance of addressing conflicts of interest in research and education. The prevalence of biased research favoring industry sponsors in nutrition and health fields poses a significant challenge to public health efforts. As such, universities and academic institutions must establish robust systems to manage conflicts of interest and uphold the integrity of their research and educational activities.
Efforts to raise awareness and implement policies to mitigate conflicts of interest, such as the ban on tobacco industry funding in academic settings, are steps in the right direction. Initiatives like online courses on research ethics and toolkits for research ethics committees provide practical guidance for dealing with conflict of interest issues in health research. By enhancing governance structures and promoting transparency, universities can better safeguard their independence and integrity in research and education.
Read the original article on Daily Maverick
